The Tesla And Solar City Merger Is Rooted In Battery Derangement Syndrome

By Mark P. Mills, Contributor


Elon Musk, CEO of Tesla [NASDAQ:TSLA], plans to buy his cousin’s company, Solar City [NASDAQ:SCTY]. That has generated a lot of head-scratching in financial circles about how it will work out. Some facts commonly cited: Tesla is the most successful and biggest electric car company the world has ever seen. Solar City is America’s biggest residential solar company. Both companies lose money. Both are deeply dependent on billions of dollars in taxpayer subsidies, and both are at the epicenter of dreams to ‘green’ the highways and the grid.

Strip away debate about operational synergies and the sustainability of subsidies and you find a single technological article-of-faith animating believers in the companies’ conjoined vision: the idea that fantastically better batteries are in the imminent future. The battery pack is by far the most expensive component in a Tesla. In a conventional car, there is no equivalent component so expensive and dominant. Fantastically better batteries are key to a future in which electric vehicles (EVs) can make a serious dent in displacing oil in transportation systems.

Similarly, the utopian vision of distributed rooftop solar is fundamentally dependent on the belief that fantastically better and cheaper batteries will soon be available to do the obvious: keep the lights, TVs and PCs lit when the sun goes down in order to dispense with the ‘old’ utility grid wherein 70 percent of the electrons derive from burning shale gas and coal. Batteries — far better than anything that exists today — are vital if rooftop solar is to make a serious dent in displacing hydrocarbons and grids used in today’s electrical systems.

Credit the New York Times with getting precisely right why Tesla and solar enthusiasts find Musk’s bold merger so exciting: “Imagine a world in which every home and building is a miniature power plant, with solar panels on the roofs and electric vehicles and stationary battery banks in the garages.” [emphasis added] The director of the Renewable and Appropriate Energy Laboratory at the University of California, Berkeley, waxed enthusiastically that Musk is on track “to build the Apple of clean energy.”

Whether successful or not, the Tesla Solar City merger offers a teaching opportunity about batteries and the scale problem tethering green dreams to earth: Given the physics of the universe we live in and the scale of the global challenge, there is simply no chance that the New York Times green vision will come to pass any time in the foreseeable future… period.

Click HERE for the rest of the story.

Liberals live in a Utopian dream world of their own making. – The Liberator

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *